New Lease: Fabric Scheme Options

I'm torn about what to do with the sofa area of my new room. I want a white sofa (is this a dangerous idea?), but I need to decide on the fabric options for the upholstered bench and throw pillows. Here are the choices I'm toying with... Which do you prefer? The sunny and fun option or the calmer, more feminine scheme?xoxTiffany LeighUpdate: The boyfriend weighed in and likes number 1 the best